Changing fate of Ukrainian refugees


THE FACT OF THE MATTER

BY PAUL HOPKINS

When Russia invaded Ukraine, Ireland opened its doors and hearts to refugees fleeing for their lives. Committees were set up, as were social media pages dedicated to finding a home, a refuge, for women and children who had been uprooted from their families, their men staying behind to fight.

The support was overwhelming, the kindness of strangers evident in their actions. Now, though, four-plus years on, the welcome has shifted somewhat off the mat, if Ukrainians seeking a refuge by way of an appeal on a social media dedicated page and getting no offer, just offensive comment, is anything to go by. Such is the capricious nature of charitable endeavour.

Now consider this. The number of non-European workers granted permits to fill vacant posts in Ireland has more than doubled since 2021, according to a new study. Irish employers are seeking more people from outside Europe for hard-to-fill jobs in construction, food and accommodation, as well as under-pressure sectors like health and technology, according to research by the European Migration Network (EMN) Ireland.

A total of 39,390 permits were issued or renewed in 2025 for workers from outside the European Economic Area (EEA), consisting of the 27 EU countries plus Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway. That still amounts to just 1.4 per cent of the total labour force last year. Indian nationals made up a third of permits issued in 2025. Brazilian and Philippine nationals made up 11 per cent each.

The total number of permits issued last year is still below a record 47,551 issued in 2003, when Ireland was in the throes of a massive economic boom and there were fewer restrictions on hiring non-EEA workers.

Now, also consider this. The number of people fleeing Ukraine who have been refused applications for temporary protection in Ireland has more than doubled in the past three months, despite Russia’s huge bombing campaign targeting civilians.

Rejected temporary protection applications from Ukraine hit 129 in September, up from 56 in July. The increase in refusals comes despite Taoiseach Micheál Martin’s recent criticism that Russia was “trying to kill as many civilians as possible” to press Ukraine to capitulate. The welcome for Ukrainians would, indeed, seem to be slipping off the mat. Note that the 107,000 Ukrainians here are not included in the asylum seekers figure as they are here under an EU directive, which at one point cost the State €1bn annually.

Almost 3,000 Ukrainian refugees were told last week that their state-supported accommodation was to close in three months. More than 700 children are expected to be affected by the move, which forms part of the Government’s plans to phase out the system by next year.

Earlier this year, the Government announced that Ukrainians who arrived here before March 2024 and were housed under the EU directive would no longer be entitled to such. As part of the Government’s plan, a further 105 accommodation contracts are to be terminated by January 31.

And speaking of accommodation, concerns for the safety of 25 people living in one semi-detached house in a Navan estate were expressed at a meeting of Meath County Council, which heard the property was used for emergency accommodation on behalf of the council.

Councillor Alan Lawes told last week’s Meath Chronicle: “This is the worst case of overcrowding in emergency accommodation I have ever seen. How so many people, including many children, who were divided into five different units upstairs, are expected to escape successfully from a fire with a high risk of blockages on pathways and exits is keeping me awake at night.”

He said that 15 people were living in five bedrooms upstairs, a couple and a single person in two bedrooms downstairs and another seven were living in two cabins in the garden.

The Navan case is far from being alone.

Overcrowded accommodation and our housing crisis aside, there are other considerations to be looked at squarely by the Government, local authorities and the courts. Such as the amount of time for asylum applications to be heard, identities to be established and the amount of time for deportations to be carried out.

The situation now regarding Ukrainians sees the new criteria dictate that temporary protection can be granted only to applicants who can show they are authorised under Ukrainian law to leave Ukraine. And applicants are no longer eligible for temporary protection in Ireland if they have already been granted such in another EU country.

Meanwhile, so-called peace talks continue…

Previous Investigating Gaelic Ireland’s Heritage
Next Feeding the Guns & Men